Skip to content

Sales Isn't Chess. It's Poker.

Nema Semnani
Nema Semnani

Play chess, not checkers. It sounds smart and maybe it is. It's just not the best parallel for sales.

There's no luck in chess. The better chess player wins 100% of the time. The closest thing to luck that exists in chess is whether the other player makes a mistake. In every chess match, the player with the best strategy who makes the fewest mistakes wins. Every time.

Sales doesn’t work that way.

Sales has more in common with poker. You don’t see the other person's cards, you make the best decisions you can with the information you have, and sometimes you do everything right and still lose. We deal in probabilities, not certainties. A perfect decision meets a bad river and you lose. Sound like any deals you've worked?

The best poker players find a way to play poker a little more like a chess player would. They can't remove the luck and they can't see the hidden cards. They bring the discipline anyway.

Resulting

Poker players have a word for the most expensive mistake in the game. Resulting. It means judging a decision by how it turned out instead of by how it was made.

We do it constantly. The deal closed, so the discount was the right call. The deal died, so we should have discounted. The prospect went dark after we attempted to schedule a clear next step, so we came on too strong. In every one of those, we're reading the river and calling it strategy.

Here's the problem. In a game with luck in it, the outcome is evidence about the decision, not proof of it. A salesperson can run a flawless discovery, qualify hard, set clear expectations, identify that the prospect’s brother-in-law owns a competing company, get the prospect to swear on a stack of Bibles it won't matter, and still lose the deal three days before signature because the prospect's wife had a different opinion. That's not a process failure, that's a one-outer on the river. Rewrite the process because of it and you've traded something that works consistently for something that would have worked on one hand.

Success Is a Poor Teacher

The opposite is worse and rarely talked about.

A salesperson can do everything wrong and win the deal. Skip the qualification, talk past the buyer, present before understanding anything, quote a number they pulled from the air, and still get the signature, because the buyer had already decided before the call started. Every mistake in that sequence just got rewarded.

Now watch what happens next. Losses get debriefed. Wins get celebrated. The deal goes in the closed column, the salesperson gets congratulated, and the whole broken sequence gets filed as something that works. They'll run it again. It'll fail the next eleven times and they won't know why, because the one time it worked is the one time anybody looked at it.

Process Over Outcome

We say this constantly in sales. Focus on the process, not the outcome. It's true and it's also easy to say in a way that means nothing, so let's make it concrete.

Winning poker strategy and winning sales strategy have much in common. Do the right things, make the right decisions, run the process correctly, and let the results land where they land on any given hand.

Making a process-based decision means you can answer one question about any call you just ran: given what I knew at the time, was that the right thing to do? Not did it work. Was it right, with the information on the table when I made it.

That question is only answerable if you had a process to begin with. Otherwise you're left with the outcome, because the outcome is the only thing you can see.

To be clear, none of this means results don't matter. Nobody is paying us for a beautiful process that never closes anything. A sales organization that can point to four straight quarters of doing everything right and still missing the number has something it needs to fix, not a luck problem. Results matter enormously. They just matter in aggregate. Winning poker players are profitable over time and still have losing sessions along the way. Same with salespeople.

A Repeatable Thought Process

Poker taught me the principle. Marc Goon at Hungry Horse Poker is the one who put it plainly. Great players aren't guessing hand to hand. They run through a repeatable thought process, the same framework every time, which is what makes it possible to look back at a hand they lost and know whether they played it well.

In sales that means replacing gut with a process you could actually hand to someone else. Gut is great until someone asks you why a deal stalled and all you can do is shrug.

Here's an example of a repeatable thought process we use with teams (as it pertains to obstacles, challenges, and opportunities):

  1. Related to the situation, what is my desired outcome? (and is it realistic or reasonable?)
  2. What's in it for the buyer to do what I want them to do?
  3. What happens if I take this action instead of another one? (What if they do something I'm not expecting? Have I considered all relevant options and consequences?)
  4. What am I assuming that might not be true?
  5. What's my next question, not (only) my next answer?
  6. What would I do next and why?
  7. How do I avoid this situation next time and what's my repeatable response when I can't?

The last two are the same in every situation by design. That's the point. If the questions changed with the circumstance, it wouldn't be a repeatable process, it would just be a series of good instincts.

Question three not only addresses the possible actions we can take but also prepares us for what we'd do next. What happens if they raise? What happens if the next card is an ace? What happens if this prospect has no budget or the champion leaves?

Ask it inwardly enough times and it comes out of your mouth differently. You start guiding the buyer in "if this, then that."

"If we both agree there's a real fit here, then the next step would be…"

You're mapping the next step together. The buyer helps write the path instead of feeling pushed.

Poker Is Not the Place for Optimism

One more borrowed from the card table.

Optimism is a wonderful trait in a person and a liability in a hand. The player who calls every bet because this could be the one has a name at the table. It isn't "optimist." It's "calling station." Every salesperson knows the equivalent. The deal that's been two weeks away for five months. The champion who's gone quiet and is definitely just busy. The pipeline number everybody in the room privately discounts.

Hope isn't a read. It's the absence of one. Folding a bad hand isn't pessimism, it's what protects the stack you're going to need when a real hand comes.

Two Things Before Anyone Runs With This

The poker skill we're borrowing is the thinking, not the bluffing. Great selling isn't deception, it’s clarity.

And the buyer isn't the player across the table. Poker has a winner and a loser. Sales, done right, has two winners. What we're borrowing is how good players think. The prospect was never the competition.

Play It Like a Chess Player

Chess rewards the better player in every single game. Poker rewards the better player over time. We're playing the second one, with hidden cards, other people's money, and circumstances we don't fully control. The discipline still applies. It's the one thing we actually control.

So the next time a deal closes, run the same debrief you'd run if it hadn't. Ask what you'd do again and what you got away with. The wins are where the bad habits hide.

Maybe don't play checkers. But don't pretend you're playing chess either. Play poker. Just play it the way a chess player would.

Share this post